Skip to main content

Candy Stuffed Peanut Butter Oatmeal Cookies

I know it's been way too long since I last posted... Shame on me but I had some technical issues (no computer). But my baking fever hasn't ceased. It is still on high gear so I have some pretty delicious recipes that are waiting to be posted :) 
But first thing first, I wanted to share this allegedly heavenly cookies. Let me tell you. These cookies are filled with snickers. Some of 'em are filled with caramel. Some of 'em are just simply with reeses. Can you honestly say that you'd resist these? Oh and they are with oatmeal and peanut butter. There is some serious richness going on here. You don't like overly sweet things? Don't worry, I don't either. That's why there is an awful lot of salt on top... AND this is how these cookies go to the next level. 

Okay, I think I owe you an explanation how I came up with this pretty bizarre creation. 
I wanted peanut butter like crazy. I'd been craving it for a veeery long time but would you think that it is so difficult to get some GOOD peanut butter in hungary? Well, it is a pretty tricky deal, indeed. So after browsing through amazon, e-bay and all kinds of other sites I ended up making my own. I thought I did a quite good job until I tasted it. 

It looked really yum and I made it with maple syrup and I made it the way I like it: crunchy. But something just went wrong...I added too much peanut oil. It got too sweet. I forgot to add salt. So everything that could have gone wrong, it had. I was bummed. So what to do with it when it is impossible to eat raw? 

Make some peanut butter cookies, of course! Only, had I known that it will mess up the cookies, as well! 
The first bite to the cookies was a huge disappointment. I could taste the nasty homemade peanut butter of mine. So what to do? I won't just throw the entire batch such days when wasting anything seems so reckless. So.... I thought stuffing some candy inside would make it a little better. Add some salt on top, just in case...And voila! :) Enjoy!

Candy Stuffed Peanut Butter Oatmeal Cookies

113 grams butter
1 1/2 cup sugar
1/3 cup peanut butter
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla
160 grams flour
1 cup oats
1/2 teaspoon baking powder
1 cup chocolate chips or 2 chocolate bars, diced
small pieces of candy - snickers, caramel, reese's PB cups, mars or any kind

Cream butter and sugar together. Add peanut butter and the egg. Mix it until fluffy. Add vanilla. In another bowl mix flour, baking powder, oats and a pinch of salt. Add the dry ingredients gradually to the wet mixture. Add in the chocolate. Form little balls and put a piece of candy on them. 

Place another cookie ball on the candy and make it into one big cookie ball. Sprinkle salt on top generously. 

Bake the cookies for about 12 minutes on 170C.


  1. I love your cookies...These are the candy bars we grew up loving. Well, I missed them terribly. I refrain from buying too much of them since I don't want my kids to get used too high sugar in their diet. But a little treat won't hurt them especially this holiday season. Incorporating them in cookies is genius! Great post!

  2. Thank you! I never eat these candies, either! But a few times a year can't be that bad ;)Candy in cookies really are awesome! Much better than eating candy plain...


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sajtos Pogácsa - Hungarian Cheese Puffs

Happy news! I have created a new, upgraded website where you can see all my old and new recipes. To see the recipe of the the Hungarian Cheese Puffs, you can simply click on the below link.

Brown Butter Walnut Cake with Chocolate-Mocha Ganache

This post is yet again an example of how I procrastinate when it comes to studying or making a presentation. Whichever. This is going to be a lovely tale about a "magnifique" cake.  I got my inspiration to make that brown butter walnut sensation from  Procrastobaker . It is seriously one of the best things I've ever baked. I do not think the photos do justice when I tried to catch how breath-taking the cake is once a bite lands in your mouth... It is crispy on the outside and so juicy in the inside and the chocolate-mocha ganache goes just perfectly well with it. I changed the original recipe a bit, as I worked with walnuts and I added a layer of chocolate cream inside the cake, as well. Also, it is important to add that it is best one day after it was made. While it chilled in the fridge. Oh my... It was such a hit! Definitely going to make it again...and again... :) But I won't keep you on your toes and fill you in with this lovely recipe! Brown Butter W

Homemade Nutella

I was an exchange student (ah how many times I've said this sentence...) 5 years ago in the US. I'm not gonna talk about how it was (AMAZING) but then and there I gained sisters! Now I have one living in the States and one living in Germany. And next week we are gonna be reunited! I can't wait, I am so excited! So this week I am going to Germany and was thinking what I should bring. Because basically Germany has everything that Hungary has, if not more. So what to give what to give? I was thinking really hard when a completely random thing came to my mind. I should make some nutella. She loves nutella. Frankly, who doesn't, right? I love it, too although it's been years since I ate any. I can't really explain why because I always think that if I eat just one spoon, I will gain a 100 pounds immediately. But with this thought, I shouldn't be eating any brownies, cookies...etc.  BUT today I tried my homemade Nutella. OH MY GOD. I wouldn't have though